My rebuttal to a Runner’s World Junk Science Article
Articles like this drive me crazy. Based on this article, to improve your 3,000 M time (and probably your 5k time as well) you should hop on a bike and do short intense reps with short rest intervals- right?
Not so fast! While there are interesting implications for runners in the story and it demonstrates that short intervals with short rest improve speed performance it does NOT by any stretch demonstrate that cycling is the best way to become a better runner!
- If you take a bunch of runners and one sub set does everything the same, and the other adds additional exercise, the ones doing extra work get faster. Duh.
- Among the ones doing extra work, the shorter rest intervals athletes improve the most. Duh.
What if your compared a group of people who did short bursts of running with short rest intervals to runners who trained with short bursts of cycling and short rest intervals? We don’t know for sure but I suspect the answer is that the principal of specificity comes into play and the runners get better at running while the athletes doing the cycling training improve some but not as much as they would if they did the running sprints.
I still don’t understand the running community’s fascination with cross-training. I love to run. Running is the best training for running. Not swimming, not cycling, not yoga, not cross fit, not burpees, not Zumba, or anything else. If you want to get better at running, RUN! Or try Cat Flexing. I’m pretty sure there’s a scientific study showing how it can help you run a faster 5k.
Do you have your fall race calendar set? The last few weeks I’ve had several people ask me what races I’m getting ready for. Honestly, I don’t have a good answer. My fall schedule is still somewhat up in the air. I have some friends who are registered for an October / November marathon as a big target race. Others who are looking for a trail ultra and some who are looking forward to a bit of fall cross country running. To help you make a plan, here are my personal recommendations. All of these are either races I’ve done before or I have first-hand knowledge of the race organizers and I have faith that they will put on a great race.
Alachua XC 5K Challenge- I ran this last year and it is a TOUGH course. Be ready for grass and hills. The course is also beautiful and the race is well organized.
September 19th : http://www.gatorzone.com/schedule.php?sport=crosm
The Mountain Dew Invitational at UF is a tradition for high school and college runners. If you can run fast enough to get in the race as an open runner (8K for men and 5K for women) it is a fast field and fun event. If you don’t want to run with the speedsters, come out to see some of the top college runners in the country and the best talent in the state for the high school races.
The Alachua Lake Half Marathon is new this year, being organized by veteran race director Bobby Burk from Lloyd Clarke Sports. There is also a Prediction 5K at the same time so if you’re not up for 13.1, do the 3.1. Considering Lloyd Clarke Sports puts on some of the best local races, you can be assured this one will also be top notch!
October 17th: http://www.lloydclarkesports.com/raceregistrationY5k.asp
Y-5K at Camp McConnell- Another inaugural race from Lloyd Clarke Sports, set at the YMCA Camp. Be ready for more than just a race with games and family fun after the 5K.
October 17th : http://www.rattlesnakerun.com/
Running with Rattlesnakes sounds fun right? The Rattlesnake Run in San Antonio Florida (just north of Tampa) is a fun event attached to the Rattlesnake Festival. Snake shows, fair food, bounce houses, and tons of fun await you after the finish line. I’ve run this one a few times over the years and it is always a good one.
October 25th: http://www.1stplacesports.com/pumpkin.html
Pumpkins line the course of this Jacksonville tradition. Run 10 miles through a beautiful and historic cemetery to get in the mood for Halloween. This is a fun, well organized event and you will go home with a free pumpkin.
November 7th: http://www.1stplacesports.com/mandarin.html
Looking for a fast 10K course to hit as the weather cools off? The Mandarin 10K is a safe bet. Flat, fast course and plenty of competition to pull you through. Early November is usually cool enough to shake off the summer slog and finally hit a fast race!
November 26th: http://www.lloydclarkesports.com/raceregistrationTT.asp
A Thanksgiving Day Tradition! The Turkey Trot has a 10K and 2 Mile so you can burn off as much turkey as you need to. Half trail and half pavement through the Tacachale Campus in east Gainesville.